How is Russian media reporting the Ukraine war? How state-controlled news coverage distorts reality

Coverage of the war in Ukraine varies hugely between countries and their allegiances – from Russia’s outright propaganda to China’s fence-sitting

The news coverage you see from the war in Ukraine depends a lot on where you live in the world.

Coverage of the conflict differs starkly across countries, from the overt propaganda of Russian state TV to the censored view available in nations with historic links to the Kremlin, most notably China.

Sign up to our NationalWorld Today newsletter

The newsletter cut through the noise

It’s a rapidly changing situation, so how exactly have news organizations in other nations reported (or misreported) on the war so far?

How Russian state media has reported the war

The state-controlled media in Russia has offered a typically distorted view of the invasion.

Russian state TV initially claimed that missile strikes on Ukrainian cities and reports of Russian soldiers killed in action were fakes.

However, even Channel One’s political talk show Vremya Pokazhet (Time Will Tell) later reported that the number of casualties could no longer be kept from the public, leading to public shock that their loved ones had been sent to fight in Ukraine.

Russian army tanks move down a street on the outskirts of Mariupol, Ukraine, March 11, 2022. (AP Photo / Evgeniy Maloletka, File)

The Moscow Times has reported on how the Western withdrawal of companies has left “Thousands of Russians’ Livelihoods on the Line” with segments of the paper delving into “Russians against War”.

However, Russian tabloid Komsomolskaya Pravda, meaning ‘Truth’, carries headlines such as “Heroes on the front lines: the sergeant personally destroyed 10 nationalists” and “Professional thugs from the Ukrainian‘ Foreign Legion ’earn $ 5,000 per day”.

There is also the ludicrous suggestion that Russia is actually helping Ukraine, with one report on the site claiming: “Since the beginning of the special operation, the Russian Ministry of Emergency Situations has delivered more than 2,000 tons of humanitarian aid to the residents of Donbass and Ukraine. ”

Inside the Moscow studios of RT, formerly known as Russia TV, which has had its broadcast license revoked in the UK (Photo: Getty)

The view from China

Chinese Foreign Minister Wang Yi insisted on Monday 14 March that China is “not a party” to the war with Ukraine. This came after US officials claimed Moscow requested military equipment from Beijing.

However, China has accused Washington of spreading ‘disinformation’ over Beijing’s stance in the Ukraine war and has repeatedly blamed the US and NATO’s ‘eastward expansion’ for worsening tensions in the region.

Vladimir Putin (L) with Chinese President Xi Jinping during their meeting in Beijing on 4 February 2022 (Photo: ALEXEI DRUZHININ / Sputnik / AFP via Getty Images)

Since the start of the Ukraine war, there has been a substantial increase in citations of Russian state media on Chinese state media, with fake reports of how American-funded biolabs in Ukraine are secretly producing chemical weapons.

Headlines such as “Russia reveals evidence of US funded bio-program in Ukraine” and “China urges US to disclose more details about biolabs in Ukraine” appear on state-run China Global Television.

A video of a Russian Defense Ministry news conference repeating these false claims has been viewed more than 10 million times on Sina Weibo and liked 90,000 times.

The BBC has revealed that social media posts expressing partisan views both for and against Russian military action are being monitored and removed by China on a daily basis.

A big screen showing the Chinese state television CCTV in Beijing (Photo: Getty)

On Weibo, China’s Twitter equivalent, one person wrote: “No-one dares to stand with Ukraine right now. It’s all one-sided support for Russia. “

According to Free Weibo, which monitors censorship on the platform, this post was one of many which was removed.

However, there are signs that even Chinese media is turning against the Russian invasion, with reports that its state media had started to report on the killing of Ukrainian civilians.

This may reflect the political pressure that China is under to condemn Russia’s invasion, as the international condemnation grows against its historic ally.

The Belarusian view

A long-time ally of Moscow, President Alexander Lukashenko is playing an increasingly prominent role in supporting Putin’s invasion of Ukraine.

Media outlets in Belarus are unsurprisingly pro-Russian in their outlook, arguing that Ukraine needs to remain outside of Western organizations.

A Russian armored vehicle drives off a railway platform after arrival in Belarus. Picture: Russian Defense Ministry Press Service via AP

Belarusian state owned newspaper Zviazda carries a piece by former Russian culture minister Vladimir Medinsky, in which he writes: “We need a peaceful, free, independent Ukraine, neutral – not a member of military blocs, not a member of NATO, a country that is our friend, neighbor with whom we develop relations, build our future, and which is not a bridgehead of the military and economic attack against our country. Therefore, our goal does not change. ”

In another article entitled “We want peace there”, President Lukashenko said: “In this situation, no Belarusian soldier is fighting in Ukraine. Despite their hostile position towards Belarus, pushed by the West, I called Zelensky and offered to enter into negotiations with Russia immediately. ”

Support people fleeing the devastating conflict in Ukraine: donate to the DEC appeal

Disasters Emergency Committee (DEC) charities and their local partners are in Ukraine and in neighboring countries providing food, water, shelter and medical assistance. Learn more and donate what you can today

A message from the editor:

Thank you for reading. NationalWorld is a new national news brand, produced by a team of journalists, editors, video producers and designers who live and work across the UK. Find out more about who’s who in the team, and our editorial values. We want to start a community among our readers, so please follow us on Facebook, Twitter and Instagram, and keep the conversation going. You can also sign up to our email newsletters and get a curated selection of our best reads to your inbox every day.

Source link

Related post